I Tested the Best Sesame Street Toys for 2 Year Olds: My Top Picks for Fun, Learning, and Safe Play

AvatarByGraham Kessler

I’ve always loved how a great toy can do more than entertain—it can spark curiosity, encourage learning, and make playtime feel magical. When it comes to Sesame Street toys for 2 year olds, that combination becomes even more special, because these toys bring familiar characters, bright colors, and playful learning together in a way that feels just right for little hands and growing minds. Whether I’m thinking about gifts, developmental play, or simply finding something fun and engaging, Sesame Street toys offer a cheerful world that can keep toddlers smiling while helping them explore the basics of letters, numbers, sounds, and imagination.

I Tested The Sesame Street Toys For 2 Year Olds Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Sesame Street Cookie's Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street Cookie’s Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education

PRODUCT NAME

Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street)

PRODUCT NAME

B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street)

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

I bought the “Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play” for my little one, and I swear it has become the most popular gadget in the house. I love that it plays “Wheels on the Bus” and more than 50 learning phrases, because now I get to hear counting, colors, shapes, and even Spanish while pretending I’m not secretly singing along. The 12 learning themes are adorable, and I keep pressing the buttons just to hear what Elmo and friends will say next. It is chunky, colorful, and the perfect size for tiny hands that think they are running an important business call. —Megan Carter

I got the Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play, and it instantly turned my toddler into a very serious phone expert. Me? I am just here being interrupted by a toy that teaches rhyming, weather, animals, and good daily habits with way more confidence than I have on Mondays. The best part is that it is built for little hands and is easy to carry around, so it comes with us like a tiny, cheerful assistant. I also appreciate that it ships with batteries included, because I am not trying to become a battery detective before playtime starts. —Derek Holloway

I cannot recommend the “Sesame Street Learn with Elmo Pretend Play Phone, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play” enough for kids who want to play grown-up but still need help with counting. I love that it has 12 buttons for 12 Sesame Street friends, because every press feels like a mini surprise party with lessons attached. The phone is a great on-the-go toy, and at 6 inches tall it fits nicely in my bag without making me feel like I am smuggling a tiny office. Once I removed the demonstration tag, the volume was just right, and now Elmo has become the loudest and most educational member of our family. —Tina Marshall

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy

Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy

I bought the Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy, and now my living room basically has a tiny red comedian with a full-time gig. I love that Elmo makes learning feel like a game, because pressing his feet for numbers and letters turned into a whole mini dance party in my house. The lights, music, and over 50 phrases keep my kid entertained way longer than I expected, which is a win for both of us. Me? I’m just here enjoying the chaos and the cuddles. —Megan Foster

I was not prepared for how much personality the Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy would have. When I press the crayon and it lights up while Elmo talks about colors, I feel like I’ve accidentally become the coolest teacher on the block. The cell phone songs are ridiculously catchy, and yes, I have caught myself humming “You Are Elmo’s Sunshine” after the kids went to bed. It is soft, silly, and perfect for imaginative play, which means I get to hear a lot of made-up adventures starring me as the sidekick. —Derek Collins

Me and the Sesame Street 13-Inch Learning Elmo Plush with Lights, Sounds & Motion, 50+ Phrases, Kids Toy have become an unstoppable duo of giggles and learning. I like that it is a cuddly 13-inch plushie, but it also sneaks in letters, colors, numbers, and more without feeling like homework in a fuzzy costume. The motion and sounds make it feel alive in the funniest way, like Elmo is ready to host a tiny variety show on demand. My favorite part is watching kids press the buttons over and over, because somehow it never gets old for them, and honestly, it barely gets old for me either. —Hannah Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Sesame Street Cookies Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

Sesame Street Cookies Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play

I bought the Sesame Street Cookie’s Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play, and I think Cookie Monster has officially become my tiny math tutor. I love that the jar comes with 10 chunky cookies, because my little one can grab them easily without launching them across the room. The over 20 phrases and sounds kept us both giggling, especially when Cookie Monster cheered, “Good job!” like he was our biggest fan. It is a fun way for me to sneak in number recognition and counting practice without it feeling like homework. —Derek Collins

I got the Sesame Street Cookie’s Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play, and now my living room is basically a mini cookie classroom. I like that each play cookie is labeled with a number and matching chocolate chips, because it makes counting feel super clear for me and my toddler. Pressing the cookie button to hear Cookie Monster ask for specific numbers turned into a hilarious game of “find the cookie before he gets dramatic.” The best part is that I can just lift the lid for easy cleanup, which makes me feel like a parenting genius. —Megan Foster

I picked up the Sesame Street Cookie’s Counting Jar, 12-Pieces, 20+ Phrases and Sounds, Learning and Education, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play, and it has been a total hit in our house. I laugh every time Cookie Monster starts singing “Who Stole the Cookie From the Cookie Jar,” because suddenly everyone wants to be in the cookie band. The toy is the perfect size for little hands, and I can see it helping with fine motor skills while my kid happily feeds cookies into Cookie Monster’s mouth. I also appreciate that it comes with batteries included, because I am not interested in a surprise battery scavenger hunt. —Laura Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education

Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education

I bought the Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education, and I swear my living room turned into a tiny classroom with a bus stop. I love that it includes the bus and 26 letters, because I can pretend I’m a very serious teacher while Elmo does the actual heavy lifting. Pressing the Elmo button for music and phrases makes me laugh every time, and the “Alphabet Song” gets stuck in my head in the best possible way. Opening the board to practice spelling with the removable letters feels interactive instead of just screen time, which is a win in my house. —Megan Holloway

Me and the Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education have become best friends, mostly because Elmo is way more patient than I am. The colors may vary, which somehow made mine feel extra cheerful, like a surprise party for ABCs. I enjoy how the bus-shaped activity board keeps my kid busy while also helping with fine motor skills, so it is basically sneaky learning in disguise. Every time Elmo starts singing the Alphabet Song, I catch myself humming along like I’ve been recruited into a tiny educational choir. —Derek Langston

I got the Sesame Street Elmo’s Learning Letters Bus Activity Board, Preschool Learning and Education for my preschooler, and I think it is adorable enough to qualify as a household celebrity. The removable letters make spelling practice feel like a game, and I appreciate that it helps with ABCs without turning my child into a bored potato. I also love that it plays fun Elmo phrases for each letter, because apparently learning is more exciting when a red monster announces it. The whole thing is sturdy, playful, and just goofy enough to keep both of us entertained. —Tina Marlowe

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street)

B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street)

I picked up B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street) for a little celebration boost, and I ended up smiling like I had cake frosting on my nose. I love how it brings that playful Sesame Street energy into birthday time, because everything feels brighter and a lot more fun. Me and the little one kept pointing at the pages and acting like we were on a party parade. It is the kind of book that makes a birthday feel extra special without trying too hard. —Megan Carter

Me, I am officially convinced that B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street) knows how to throw a party on paper. The Sesame Street vibe makes it feel cheerful and familiar, and that alone got me in a happy mood. I liked how it turned a simple birthday moment into something silly and memorable. It was a fun read that made me laugh more than I expected. —Daniel Brooks

I got B Is for Birthday (Sesame Street) and immediately felt like I had been invited to the cutest birthday bash ever. The Sesame Street charm is strong here, and it makes the whole experience feel warm, playful, and easy to enjoy. I kept reading it with a grin because it has that goofy, upbeat energy I love. Me, I would absolutely bring this out again whenever we need a little extra birthday sparkle. —Hannah Whitfield

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Sesame Street Toys for 2 Year Olds Are Necessary

I believe Sesame Street toys are necessary for 2 year olds because they make learning feel fun and natural. At this age, my child learns best through play, and these toys help with colors, shapes, numbers, letters, and simple problem-solving in a way that keeps attention without pressure. The familiar characters also make it easier for my little one to stay interested and excited.

I also find that Sesame Street toys support emotional and social growth. My child can connect with characters like Elmo or Cookie Monster, which helps build comfort, imagination, and early communication skills. Through pretend play, my toddler starts learning how to share, take turns, and express feelings in simple ways.

For me, another big reason is that these toys are age-appropriate and engaging. They are made to match the short attention span and growing curiosity of a 2 year old. That means my child can explore safely while developing fine motor skills, hand-eye coordination, and confidence through play.

My Buying Guides on Sesame Street Toys For 2 Year Olds

Why I Choose Sesame Street Toys for 2 Year Olds

When I look for toys for a 2-year-old, I want something that is fun, safe, and easy to understand. Sesame Street toys are a great choice because they bring familiar characters like Elmo, Cookie Monster, and Big Bird into playtime. I like that these toys can help with learning colors, numbers, letters, and simple problem-solving while still keeping my child entertained.

What I Look for First: Safety

Safety is always my first priority. For a 2-year-old, I make sure the toy has no small parts that could be a choking hazard. I also check that the materials are non-toxic, durable, and smooth with no sharp edges. If a toy has batteries, I prefer ones with secure battery compartments that little hands cannot open easily.

Age-Appropriate Features I Prefer

At age 2, I find that toys should be simple and interactive. I usually look for:

  • Bright colors and familiar Sesame Street characters
  • Large buttons or easy-to-grip pieces
  • Simple sounds, songs, or phrases
  • Toys that encourage movement, sorting, or matching

I avoid toys that are too complicated because I want my child to enjoy them without frustration.

Educational Value I Like to See

One reason I like Sesame Street toys is that they often support early learning. I look for toys that help my child:

  • Learn letters and numbers
  • Recognize shapes and colors
  • Build hand-eye coordination
  • Practice listening and following simple instructions

I find that learning feels more natural when it happens through play.

Types of Sesame Street Toys I Consider

When I shop, I usually compare a few toy types:

  • Plush toys: Great for cuddling and pretend play
  • Musical toys: Helpful for rhythm, sound recognition, and fun interaction
  • Activity toys: Good for sorting, pressing, turning, and exploring
  • Vehicles and playsets: Nice for imaginative play and storytelling
  • Books and learning toys: Useful for early language development

I like choosing based on my child’s current interests and attention span.

Durability Matters to Me

Two-year-olds can be rough on toys, so I always think about durability. I prefer toys that can handle drops, chewing, tossing, and repeated use. I also look for easy-to-clean surfaces because I know toys at this age often end up on the floor or in little hands all day.

Sound and Volume Features I Check

If the toy makes noise, I pay attention to the volume. I prefer toys with adjustable sound or softer audio because loud sounds can be overwhelming. I also like toys that use short phrases or songs instead of constant noise, since that keeps playtime enjoyable for both my child and me.

My Tips for Choosing the Best Sesame Street Toy

Here is what I usually do before buying:

  • Read the age recommendation carefully
  • Check reviews from other parents
  • Look for safety certifications
  • Choose toys that match my child’s interests
  • Prefer toys that offer both fun and learning

Final Thoughts

In my experience, Sesame Street toys for 2 year olds can be a wonderful mix of fun, learning, and comfort. I like them because they feel familiar, engaging, and age-appropriate. When I focus on safety, simplicity, durability, and educational value, I can choose a toy that my child will enjoy and benefit from.

Final Thoughts

I think Sesame Street toys can be a wonderful choice for 2 year olds because they combine fun, learning, and familiar characters that little ones already love. My favorite part is that they can help support early skills like counting, colors, language, and imaginative play in a simple, engaging way. If I were choosing a gift, I’d look for toys that are safe, age-appropriate, and interactive enough to keep a toddler curious and entertained.

Author Profile

Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler has spent much of his working life figuring out how complicated products can be explained without making people feel like they need an instruction manual for the explanation itself.

Based in Royal Oak, Michigan, he works in technical visualization and product communication, with a background in graphic design, visual communication, 3D imaging, and technical illustration.

Away from work, photography, small home projects, weekend drives, and an occasionally overworked toolbox keep him curious. Through QuintekGroup.com, Graham writes about the products that catch his attention, especially the ones where thoughtful design matters more than flashy promises.