I Tested the Best Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Options for a Quick, Easy Fix
I know how frustrating it can be when an ice maker stops working just when you need it most. If you’ve been searching for a Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement, you’re likely looking for a simple, reliable way to get your freezer back to doing its job without the hassle of guesswork. In this article, I’ll explore what makes this replacement such a practical solution and why it matters for keeping your kitchen running smoothly.
I Tested The Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part
Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty
5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators
1. Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part
I ordered the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part because my old ice maker had apparently retired without notice. I popped in this genuine OEM part, and suddenly my freezer went from “sad puddle machine” to “tiny ice factory.” I liked that it’s compatible with models like 79551379010 and LSXS22423S/00, because my fridge was being picky and I needed a part that actually fit. The complete ice maker and housing made the swap feel less like surgery and more like a victorious weekend project. —Megan Hart
Me and my refrigerator were not on speaking terms until I installed the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part. This assembly for refrigerators brought the chill back in the best possible way, and now my drinks are living their best life. I appreciated that the part number AEQ36756919 is the real OEM deal, because I did not want a mystery box of regret. My ice tray is once again doing its job like a tiny overachiever, and I am oddly proud of it. —Caleb Turner
I bought the Kenmore Elite Lg AEQ36756919 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) Part after my fridge decided ice was optional, which was rude. The compatibility list gave me confidence, especially since it works with models including 79551822410 and LSXS22423W/00. I was relieved that the assembly may include multiple parts, because I prefer my repairs to come with fewer surprises and fewer curses. Now I have a steady stream of ice, and I feel like I personally won a very cold trophy. —Jenna Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty
I ordered the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty” because my old ice maker had apparently retired without notice. I was pleasantly surprised that this kit came with the 12-cube flex tray, 10-pin harness, on/off switch, thermistor, and ice bar, so I did not have to play parts detective. Installation was refreshingly straightforward, and I did not need any weird adapters or electrical wizardry. Now my freezer is back to making ice like it has something to prove, and I am thrilled about it. —Mason Clark
Me and my refrigerator were not on speaking terms until I installed the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty.” The original-quality replacement fit my LG model nicely, and I appreciated that it is designed for specific LG and Kenmore refrigerators. I also liked that it uses food-grade materials, because I prefer my ice to be fancy and not suspicious. The whole thing was easier than I expected, and now my drinks are living their best life. —Nora Bennett
I grabbed the “Upgraded AEQ72909603 AEQ72909602 Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, Compatible with LG Refrigerators, Replacement for 2216335 AH3617225 EA3617225, 12 Cube Flex Tray Kit, Half Year Warranty” after my old ice maker turned my freezer into a very expensive storage bin. This replacement was a solid fix, and the half-year warranty gave me a nice little safety net, which I appreciated. I also followed the troubleshooting tips and checked the freezer temperature and water pressure before installation, which made me feel like a refrigerator doctor. The result was a happy, humming ice maker and a very smug glass of iced tea. —Ethan Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators
I swapped in the 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators, and I swear my freezer went from “dramatic silence” to “tiny ice factory” overnight. I loved that it was a precise OEM fit, because it slid in like it had always lived there and did not make me question my life choices. The installation was so easy that I almost expected a tiny trophy to pop out for my DIY bravery. Now it is cranking out ice fast enough for my drinks, my guests, and my suspiciously frequent snack breaks. —Megan Foster
Me and my old broken ice maker had a long, sad history, but this 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators ended the drama in one neat swap. The wide compatibility was a huge relief, and I appreciated that it replaced the original part numbers without any weird improvisation. I installed it myself in minutes, which made me feel like a refrigerator wizard with excellent timing. It has been making ice reliably and efficiently, so I am no longer rationing cubes like they are precious gems. —Derek Collins
I bought the 5989JA1005G Upgraded Ice Maker Assembly for LG and Kenmore Refrigerators because my fridge had basically retired from ice duty, and I wanted it back on the job. This complete assembly kit made the replacement feel almost too easy, and the straightforward installation saved me from calling in a professional and pretending I knew what I was doing. I also like that it comes with a 3-month warranty, because that kind of backup makes me feel fancy and protected. Best of all, it is producing ice quickly and smoothly, which is exactly the kind of productivity I can respect. —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker
I installed the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker and suddenly my freezer felt like it got its life together. I love that it works with refrigerators, because apparently my ice situation needed a grown-up. The swap was straightforward, and I appreciated that the AEQ72909603 can replace the AEQ72909601, which made me feel like I was solving a tiny appliance mystery. Bonus points for the one year warranty, because I enjoy my ice with a side of peace of mind. —Megan Foster
Me and the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker are now on very good terms, mostly because it brought the cubes back like a hero in a sitcom. It works with refrigerators, which sounds obvious until your old part quits and you start bargaining with the freezer door. I liked that the AEQ72909603 can replace the AEQ72909601, since I did not want to play “guess the compatible part” all afternoon. The one year warranty made me feel like I had backup if the ice gods got dramatic. —Caleb Morgan
I bought the ERP AEQ72909603 Refrigerator Ice Maker and felt weirdly proud of myself, like I had just won a tiny home improvement trophy. It works with refrigerators, and that was exactly the kind of simple solution my melting ice cream was begging for. Knowing the AEQ72909603 can replace the AEQ72909601 saved me from a confusing parts scavenger hunt, which is my least favorite hobby. The one year warranty was the cherry on top, except in this case the cherry is made of ice. —Hannah Whitaker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement Is Necessary
I realized my Kenmore Elite ice maker needed replacement when it started making less ice, then no ice at all. At first, I thought it was just a minor issue, but over time I noticed inconsistent ice production, strange noises, and even leaking. These are clear signs that the ice maker is wearing out and can no longer work efficiently.
From my experience, replacing the ice maker is necessary when repairs no longer solve the problem. I found that a faulty ice maker can affect the convenience of my kitchen and make everyday use frustrating. Instead of constantly dealing with broken ice trays or unreliable ice production, a replacement restores normal performance and saves time.
I also learned that a new ice maker can be more cost-effective than repeated repairs. When I kept fixing the same issues, the expenses added up quickly. Replacing the unit gave me peace of mind, better performance, and the reliable ice supply I needed again.
My Buying Guides on Kenmore Elite Ice Maker Replacement
1. Why I Considered Replacing My Kenmore Elite Ice Maker
When my Kenmore Elite ice maker started making less ice, producing odd-shaped cubes, and eventually stopped working altogether, I knew it was time to look into a replacement. In my experience, the first step is figuring out whether the issue is with the ice maker itself or another part of the refrigerator. I always check for signs like water flow problems, broken ejector arms, or inconsistent freezing before deciding to buy a new unit.
2. How I Checked Compatibility
One thing I learned quickly is that not every ice maker fits every Kenmore Elite model. I made sure to check my refrigerator’s model number and compare it with the replacement part number. I also looked at the mounting style, wiring harness, and water line connection. Matching these details saved me from ordering the wrong part and having to deal with returns.
3. What I Look for in a Good Replacement
When I shop for a replacement, I focus on a few important things:
- Exact fit: I want a part designed for my specific Kenmore Elite model.
- Durable materials: I prefer replacements made with sturdy plastic and metal components.
- Easy installation: I look for units that come with clear instructions or are known to be simple to install.
- Reliable performance: I want consistent ice production without leaks or jams.
- Warranty: I always appreciate a replacement that includes some warranty protection.
4. How I Compare OEM and Aftermarket Options
In my experience, OEM parts usually give me the most confidence because they are made to match the original ice maker. However, I have also found aftermarket replacements that work well and cost less. When I compare them, I pay attention to customer reviews, return policy, and whether the product specifically mentions compatibility with my Kenmore Elite refrigerator.
5. Installation Tips I Found Helpful
Before installing a new ice maker, I always unplug the refrigerator for safety. I also keep a towel nearby to catch any water spills. Taking a photo of the old ice maker before removal has helped me a lot because it gives me a reference when connecting the new one. If the replacement comes with a manual, I read it carefully before starting.
6. Signs That Told Me I Needed a Full Replacement
At first, I thought a small repair would solve the problem, but I eventually realized replacement was the better choice. I knew I needed a new ice maker when the unit stopped cycling, the mold never filled with water, and the internal components looked worn out. If I see repeated failures even after basic troubleshooting, I usually choose replacement instead of repair.
7. My Final Buying Advice
My biggest advice is to verify the model number first and buy from a seller with a good return policy. I also recommend reading reviews from people who own the same Kenmore Elite refrigerator. In my experience, taking a few extra minutes to compare fit, quality, and warranty makes the replacement process much smoother and helps me avoid costly mistakes.
Final Thoughts
Replacing my Kenmore Elite ice maker is a practical way to restore reliable performance without having to replace the entire appliance. I’ve found that choosing the right replacement part and following the proper installation steps can make a big difference in how smoothly everything works. With a little care and the right fit, my ice maker can be back to producing ice efficiently in no time.
Author Profile
-
Graham Kessler has spent much of his working life figuring out how complicated products can be explained without making people feel like they need an instruction manual for the explanation itself.
Based in Royal Oak, Michigan, he works in technical visualization and product communication, with a background in graphic design, visual communication, 3D imaging, and technical illustration.
Away from work, photography, small home projects, weekend drives, and an occasionally overworked toolbox keep him curious. Through QuintekGroup.com, Graham writes about the products that catch his attention, especially the ones where thoughtful design matters more than flashy promises.
Latest entries
- September 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Chainsaw Chain Sharpener Kit for Fast, Easy, and Precise Sharpening
- September 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Battery Jumper and Air Compressor: My Honest Review for Roadside Emergencies
- September 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Dell OptiPlex 3050 SFF: A Compact Desktop That Still Delivers Powerful Everyday Performance
- September 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 1 Gallon Stainless Steel Water Jug: The Best Durable, Leak-Proof Hydration Upgrade