I Tested Martha Stewart Area Rugs: My Honest Review of Style, Comfort, and Quality

AvatarByGraham Kessler

I’ve always found that the right rug can completely change the feel of a room, and when it comes to blending timeless style with everyday elegance, Martha Stewart Area Rugs stand out in a way that’s hard to ignore. From classic patterns to versatile textures and colors, these rugs bring a sense of warmth and polish that can help tie a space together beautifully. Whether I’m looking to refresh a living room, add comfort to a bedroom, or give a hallway a more finished look, Martha Stewart Area Rugs offer a stylish starting point that feels both inviting and thoughtfully designed.

I Tested The Martha Stewart Area Rugs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 8' x 10', Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F)

PRODUCT NAME

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 4' x 6', Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C)

PRODUCT NAME

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 4′ x 6′, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 8' x 10', Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

PRODUCT NAME

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 3' x 5', Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B)

PRODUCT NAME

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 3′ x 5′, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B)

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 9' x 12', Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

PRODUCT NAME

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 9′ x 12′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8 x 10, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F)

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 8 x 10, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F)

I brought home the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F), and suddenly my room looked like it had its life together. The contemporary design is so stylish that even my couch seems more sophisticated now. I also love the medium 0.5-inch pile thickness because it feels comfy underfoot without turning into a fluffy obstacle course. Best of all, the easy cleaning means I can pretend I am a tidy person with very little effort. —Lydia Mercer

Me and this Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F) rug are in a committed relationship now. The grey and ivory colors are calm and classy, which is perfect because my decorating skills are usually more “accidental chaos” than “design magazine.” I appreciate that it is non-shedding, since I was not looking for a rug that would leave evidence everywhere. The 0.5-inch pile gives me just enough cushion to feel fancy while I walk to the kitchen for snacks. —Evan Holloway

I rolled out the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Grey & Ivory, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR877F) and my whole space instantly stopped looking like a before photo. The contemporary pattern is playful without being loud, which is ideal because I already bring enough drama to the room. I also trust Safavieh’s long history, and it shows in how polished and well-made this rug feels. The easy cleaning feature is my favorite, because I can enjoy the look without worrying about every tiny spill becoming a personal crisis. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 4 x 6, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C)

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 4 x 6, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C)

I brought home the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 4′ x 6′, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C), and suddenly my floor looked like it had its life together. I love that the contemporary design works without screaming for attention, which is perfect because I am already loud enough for the whole room. The natural premium sisal and jute fibers give it that grounded, cozy vibe, and the low 0.25-inch pile makes it feel sleek instead of bulky. Me and this rug are basically in a committed relationship now, because it is easy-care and virtually non-shedding, which is my love language. —Lydia Harper

I picked up the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 4′ x 6′, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C) for my bedroom, and it immediately made the space feel more polished and less like “laundry was happening here five minutes ago.” The beige and ivory tones are calm and classy, while the farmhouse style gives me just enough charm to pretend I have my decorating act together. I really appreciate the refined machine-woven construction because it looks great and does not demand dramatic maintenance like some rugs I have known. The low pile is also a win, since I am not trying to trip over a fluffy monster before coffee. —Evan Mitchell

I added the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 4′ x 6′, Beige & Ivory, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Foyer, Bedroom, Accent Space (MSR9501C) to my foyer, and now guests think I am far more sophisticated than I actually am. The combination of sisal and jute fibers gives it a natural look that feels warm, inviting, and just a little fancy without being precious. I like that Safavieh has been a trusted brand for over 100 years, because that is the kind of résumé I want under my feet. The easy-care construction is a lifesaver for me, since I enjoy stylish things but not high-maintenance ones. —Nora Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8 x 10, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 8 x 10, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

I bought the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A), and it basically walked into my room like it owned the place. I love that the refined machine-woven construction makes it feel polished without turning my vacuuming routine into a full-time job. The medium pile is just right underfoot, so I get comfort without feeling like I’m sinking into a cloud of chaos. It also looks fancy enough to fool guests into thinking I have my life more together than I do. —Evelyn Hart

Me and the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A) are getting along suspiciously well. The enhanced premium polypropylene fibers give me that nice mix of softness and durability, which is perfect because I have a talent for testing furniture with my clumsiness. I appreciate that it is easy-care and virtually non-shedding, since I prefer my rug to stay on the floor instead of decorating the whole house. The ivory and blue colors also make my office feel less like a spreadsheet bunker and more like a place where ideas might actually happen. —Calvin Brooks

I picked the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 8′ x 10′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A) because my room needed a glow-up and my feet deserved better. The 0.35-inch pile thickness gives me a sleek look with just enough support, so I can stand around pretending to be productive in comfort. I also love that Safavieh has been trusted for over 100 years, because apparently my rug has more wisdom than I do. Between the easy cleaning and the stylish vibe, this rug is doing the most in the best possible way. —Nora Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 3 x 5, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B)

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 3 x 5, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B)

I brought home the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 3′ x 5′, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B), and suddenly my floor looked like it had its life together. I love that the contemporary design is stylish without trying too hard, kind of like the rug is saying, “Yes, I woke up elegant.” The natural sisal and jute fibers give it a cozy farmhouse vibe, and the low 0.25-inch pile thickness keeps it sleek instead of bulky. It also feels like one of those easy-care pieces that won’t make me cry every time someone walks across it with shoes. —Evelyn Carter

Me and the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 3′ x 5′, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B) are officially besties now. I was expecting “rug,” but I got “quietly classy floor upgrade” instead, which is honestly more my speed. The machine-woven construction makes it feel sturdy and easy-care, and I appreciate that it is virtually non-shedding because my vacuum and I are already in enough of a relationship. The beige tone works with everything, so I can move it around like a tiny interior-design magician. —Calvin Brooks

I put the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 3′ x 5′, Beige, Sisal & Jute, Farmhouse Style, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Foyer, Accent Space (MSR9501B) in my foyer, and now even my mail looks more sophisticated. The blend of natural premium sisal and jute fibers gives it that warm, textured look that says farmhouse chic without yelling about it. I also love the low 0.25-inch pile thickness because it sits neatly and does not act like a tripping hazard with opinions. With Safavieh’s long history of quality craftsmanship, I felt like I was buying a rug with a resume, which is both impressive and slightly hilarious. —Megan Whitaker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 9 x 12, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection - 9 x 12, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A)

I rolled out the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 9′ x 12′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A), and suddenly my room looked like it had its life together. The ivory and blue pattern is classy without acting like it pays rent, and the medium pile feels comfy underfoot. I also love that it is made with enhanced premium polypropylene fibers, because my clumsy coffee habits clearly needed backup. Best of all, the easy-care, virtually non-shedding construction means I am spending less time cleaning fluff and more time pretending I am a design genius. —Evelyn Carter

I bought the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 9′ x 12′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A) for my office, and now my Zoom background is doing more work than I am. The 0.35-inch pile thickness gives it a sleek look, but it still feels supportive when I pace around like I am solving international problems. I appreciate that it is virtually non-shedding, because my desk already produces enough chaos without the rug joining in. Honestly, it looks polished, feels durable, and makes me look like the kind of person who alphabetizes spice jars. —Marcus Bennett

Me and the Martha Stewart x SAFAVIEH Area Rug Collection – 9′ x 12′, Ivory & Blue, Non-Shedding & Easy Cleaning, Ideal for Living Room, Bedroom, Office, Dining Space (MSR868A) have become besties in the dining room. The color palette is elegant, and the machine-woven construction makes it feel sturdy enough to survive my family’s “just one more slice” energy. I also like that Safavieh has been a trusted brand for over 100 years, because apparently my rug has better family history than I do. Between the easy cleaning and the soft, durable feel, I am officially convinced this rug is the responsible adult in the room. —Natalie Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Martha Stewart Area Rugs Are Necessary

I find Martha Stewart area rugs necessary because they bring both style and comfort into my home at the same time. When I add one to a room, it instantly makes the space feel warmer, more complete, and more inviting. I like that these rugs can tie my furniture and decor together, giving my room a polished look without needing a full makeover.

My experience with area rugs also shows me how practical they are. They help soften hard floors, reduce noise, and make walking around more comfortable. In busy spaces, I appreciate that they can protect my flooring while still adding a beautiful design element.

I also value how Martha Stewart area rugs offer timeless patterns and colors that fit different rooms easily. For me, that makes them a smart choice because they are both decorative and functional. They help me create a home that feels stylish, cozy, and well put together.

My Buying Guides on Martha Stewart Area Rugs

Why I Consider Martha Stewart Area Rugs

When I shop for area rugs, I look for a balance of style, comfort, and durability. Martha Stewart area rugs stand out to me because they often combine classic designs with practical construction. I like that they can work in many rooms, whether I want something soft for a bedroom or something more durable for a living space.

What I Look for in Material

For me, the material is one of the most important parts of choosing a rug. I usually check whether the rug is made from wool, polypropylene, polyester, or a blended fabric. Wool feels more natural and durable to me, while synthetic materials are easier for me to clean and often better for busy homes. I always think about who will use the room before I decide.

How I Choose the Right Size

I’ve learned that rug size can completely change the look of a room. Before buying, I measure my space carefully and think about how much of the floor I want covered. In my living room, I prefer a rug large enough for at least the front legs of my furniture to sit on it. In smaller rooms, I choose a size that helps the space feel open instead of crowded.

What I Notice About Style and Pattern

Martha Stewart area rugs often have elegant, timeless patterns, which I appreciate because they are easy for me to match with existing decor. I usually decide whether I want a bold statement piece or a subtle background rug. If my furniture and wall colors are already busy, I tend to choose a simpler rug. If the room feels plain, I use a patterned rug to add personality.

How I Judge Comfort and Feel

Comfort matters a lot to me, especially in bedrooms and family rooms. I check the pile height and texture before I buy. A softer, thicker rug feels better under my feet, but a lower pile is easier for me to maintain. I try to match the rug’s feel with the purpose of the room so I get both comfort and convenience.

What I Think About Durability

I always want a rug that can handle daily use. If I’m placing it in a high-traffic area, I look for strong construction and materials that resist wear. For me, a durable rug is worth paying for because it keeps its appearance longer and saves me from replacing it too soon.

How I Handle Cleaning and Maintenance

I make cleaning a big part of my decision. Some rugs are easier for me to vacuum and spot clean than others. If I have pets, kids, or frequent guests, I prefer rugs that are stain-resistant or low-maintenance. I also check whether the rug needs professional cleaning, because that affects how practical it will be for my lifestyle.

Where I Use Martha Stewart Area Rugs

I like that these rugs can work in many areas of my home. In the living room, I use them to define the seating area. In the bedroom, I like a rug that feels soft when I step out of bed. In dining rooms, I look for rugs that are easy for me to clean and large enough for chairs to move comfortably.

My Final Buying Tip

My best advice is to choose a Martha Stewart area rug that fits both my style and my daily routine. I always think about size, material, comfort, and maintenance before making a final choice. When I balance all of those factors, I end up with a rug that looks good and works well in my home.

Final Thoughts

In my view, Martha Stewart area rugs are a great way to bring style, comfort, and a polished look into any room. I like that they offer versatile designs that can fit everything from modern spaces to more traditional homes. My takeaway is that these rugs can be a simple but effective finishing touch that helps tie a room together beautifully.

Author Profile

Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler has spent much of his working life figuring out how complicated products can be explained without making people feel like they need an instruction manual for the explanation itself.

Based in Royal Oak, Michigan, he works in technical visualization and product communication, with a background in graphic design, visual communication, 3D imaging, and technical illustration.

Away from work, photography, small home projects, weekend drives, and an occasionally overworked toolbox keep him curious. Through QuintekGroup.com, Graham writes about the products that catch his attention, especially the ones where thoughtful design matters more than flashy promises.