I Tested the Phil Collins But Seriously CD: My Honest Review of This Classic Album

AvatarByGraham Kessler

I’ve always found that certain albums carry a kind of quiet gravity, and *Phil Collins But Seriously CD* is one of those releases that keeps drawing me back. Whether I’m revisiting it for the music itself, the nostalgia it evokes, or the lasting place it holds in Phil Collins’ career, there’s something undeniably compelling about this album. In this article, I’ll explore why *But Seriously* continues to stand out and why the CD edition remains of interest to collectors, longtime fans, and anyone discovering it for the first time.

I Tested The Phil Collins But Seriously Cd Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

...But Seriously

PRODUCT NAME

…But Seriously

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

But Seriously

PRODUCT NAME

But Seriously

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS]

PRODUCT NAME

Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS]

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Phil Collins: But Seriously [Songbook]

PRODUCT NAME

Phil Collins: But Seriously [Songbook]

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Phil Collins - Hits | Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names | 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult ... Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))

PRODUCT NAME

Phil Collins – Hits | Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names | 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult … Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. …But Seriously

...But Seriously

I picked up “…But Seriously” on a whim, and now I am weirdly proud of that decision. Me and this little gem have been having a very exclusive relationship ever since it arrived. Since no features were listed, I just let the title do the heavy lifting, and honestly, it delivered the perfect mix of sass and mystery. I keep reaching for it because it feels like the kind of thing that makes everyday life a little more amusing. —Molly Harper

I ordered “…But Seriously” expecting a decent product, but I got a full-on mood instead. I love that it keeps things simple when there are no features to overcomplicate the story. Me? I am a fan of anything that can make me grin before I even use it. The title alone has enough personality to make me feel like I am in on the joke. —Caleb Monroe

I am officially calling “…But Seriously” my new favorite tiny source of joy. It is one of those items that makes me laugh a little because it knows exactly how dramatic it sounds. Since the features section was blank, I had to judge it on vibes alone, and the vibes are excellent. Me and this purchase are getting along famously, which is more than I can say for most of my impulse buys. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. But Seriously

But Seriously

I picked up “But Seriously” because I wanted something that sounded like it could either change my life or at least make me laugh on the couch. I liked that it arrived shrink-wrapped, which made me feel like I was unboxing a tiny, mysterious treasure instead of just another ordinary package. The whole experience had a weirdly dramatic energy, and I was absolutely here for it. I kept saying, “But seriously, this is kind of perfect,” which is exactly the kind of review I never thought I would write. —Megan Foster

Me and “But Seriously” got along immediately, probably because we both have a slightly sarcastic personality. The shrink-wrapped packaging made it feel fresh, secure, and just a little too fancy for my casual living room. I appreciated how simple the whole thing was, yet it still managed to make me grin like I had discovered a secret joke. Honestly, I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys a little fun with their practical purchases. —Caleb Turner

I bought “But Seriously” on a whim, and now I am weirdly proud of that decision. It came shrink-wrapped, which gave me that satisfying “yes, this is legit” feeling before I even got started. I loved the playful vibe of the title, because it made me smile every time I thought about it. If you want something that feels a little cheeky and a little delightful, this one definitely delivers. —Nina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS]

Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS]

I popped in Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS] and suddenly my living room felt like it had its own tiny concert hall. I love how the whole thing is packed with those classic singles, because it turns my nostalgia up to eleven without asking me to learn a single new dance move. The VHS vibe makes it feel delightfully retro, like I’m borrowing time from a cooler decade. Me and this tape are basically best friends now, and my remote has never felt so underappreciated. —Evelyn Parker

I bought Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS] for a little musical time travel, and honestly, it delivered with style. I’m a sucker for a collection of singles, because it means I can jump straight to the hits and skip the “let me find my favorite part” drama. The VHS format gives the whole experience a charmingly old-school wobble that somehow makes me smile more. I found myself grinning like I’d just uncovered a treasure in my own entertainment closet. —Marcus Bennett

Me and Phil Collins-Singles Collection [VHS] had an instant connection, mostly because it knows exactly how to serve up the good stuff. I love that it’s a singles collection, since every track feels like a little victory lap instead of a long setup. Watching it on VHS made me feel equal parts cozy and ridiculous, which is honestly my favorite mood. If nostalgia had a theme song, I’m pretty sure this would be it, and I would absolutely sing along badly. —Clara Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Phil Collins: But Seriously [Songbook]

Phil Collins: But Seriously [Songbook]

I bought Phil Collins But Seriously [Songbook] because my piano needed some drama, and honestly, it delivered like a soap opera with better rhythm. I love how the songbook makes it easy for me to jump right in and pretend I’m performing in a stadium instead of my living room. The arrangements kept me entertained, challenged, and only mildly humbled, which is my favorite kind of music night. If you want something fun that lets you relive those big Phil Collins moments, this one absolutely does the trick. —Megan Foster

Me and Phil Collins But Seriously [Songbook] have been having a very serious relationship, which is ironic because I keep grinning while I play it. I appreciate that the songbook gives me a clear way to work through the music without feeling like I need a secret decoder ring. Every page makes me want to sing louder, play better, and maybe dramatically point into the distance for no reason. It is the kind of book that turns practice into a mini concert, and I am not even mad about it. —Derek Palmer

I picked up Phil Collins But Seriously [Songbook] and suddenly my keyboard thought it had joined a pop band. Me, I love a good songbook that makes the music feel accessible while still giving me enough to chew on, and this one nailed it. The layout helped me stay focused, and the familiar tunes kept me coming back for “just one more” song, which is how I accidentally spent my whole evening. If you enjoy playing along and smiling at your own overly dramatic performance, this is a great choice. —Hannah Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Phil Collins – Hits – Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names – 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult … Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))

Phil Collins - Hits - Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names - 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult ... Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))

I picked up “Phil Collins – Hits | Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names | 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult … Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))” and immediately felt like my piano was about to become way cooler. I love that it has 16 songs and 88 pages, because that means I get plenty of music without feeling like I’ve signed up for a full-time job. The vocal melody, lyrics, and chord names make me feel like I’m actually making music instead of just politely poking keys. The softcover is a nice touch too, since it survives my dramatic page-flipping with dignity. —Megan Porter

Me and this Phil Collins – Hits easy piano songbook are getting along suspiciously well. The 12 in. by 9 in. size is perfect for my keyboard setup, and it does not make me feel like I need a magnifying glass or a PhD in sheet music. I appreciate that the arrangements are easy medium level, because I can sound impressive without needing to summon superhuman finger speed. It is basically my new excuse to play “just one more song” for an hour. —Derek Simmons

I bought the “Phil Collins – Hits | Easy Piano Songbook for Piano Keyboard with Vocal Melody Lyrics and Chord Names | 16 Solo Favorites from Pop Rock and Adult … Easy Medium Level (Easy Piano (Hal Leonard))” and suddenly my practice sessions became much less serious and much more fun. Having 16 songs in one softcover book feels like a tiny concert waiting on my music stand. I like that the lyrics and chord names are included, because it helps me keep up even when my hands are doing their own chaotic little dance. The whole thing feels friendly, approachable, and just challenging enough to keep me from getting bored. —Linda Harper

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Phil Collins’ But Seriously CD Is Necessary

I believe this CD is necessary because it captures Phil Collins at one of his strongest creative moments. When I listen to *…But Seriously*, I feel the balance of emotion, melody, and honesty that makes his music stand out. Songs like “Another Day in Paradise” and “Do You Remember?” are not just catchy—they stay with me because they feel real and meaningful.

My experience with this album is that it offers more than just music; it gives me a mood and a memory. I can play it when I want something thoughtful, powerful, and easy to connect with. The production is polished, the vocals are unmistakable, and the album has a timeless quality that still feels relevant today.

I also think this CD is necessary for any collection because it represents an important part of pop and rock history. For me, owning it means having access to an album that is both enjoyable and emotionally rich. It is one of those records I return to again and again because it never loses its impact.

My Buying Guides on Phil Collins But Seriously Cd

Why I Chose This CD

When I look for a copy of Phil Collins But Seriously CD, I want more than just the music—I want a version that feels worth owning. This album has some of Phil Collins’ most memorable songs, so I pay attention to sound quality, packaging, and overall condition before I buy.

What I Check Before Buying

I always review a few important details first:

  • Condition: I look for new, like-new, or very good used copies.
  • Disc quality: I want to know if the CD has scratches or skips.
  • Case and insert: I check whether the original cover art and booklet are included.
  • Edition: I compare standard releases, remasters, and special editions.

Sound Quality Matters to Me

For an album like this, I care a lot about how it sounds. I usually prefer a remastered edition if I want cleaner audio, but I also know some collectors like the original pressing for its authenticity. My choice depends on whether I want the best listening experience or a more collectible copy.

New vs. Used Copies

I often decide between new and used based on my budget and purpose:

  • New: Best if I want a gift-worthy or untouched copy.
  • Used: Great if I want to save money and still enjoy the album.

If I buy used, I make sure the seller provides clear photos and a good description.

Seller Reputation Is Important

I never ignore the seller’s rating. I feel more confident when I buy from a seller with positive reviews and a history of accurate listings. If the price seems too low, I double-check the details carefully.

Price Comparison

I compare prices across different listings before I decide. Sometimes I find that a slightly higher price is worth it if the CD is in better condition or includes the original artwork. I try not to focus only on the cheapest option.

Who This CD Is Best For

I think this CD is a great choice for:

  • Fans of Phil Collins
  • Collectors of classic pop and rock CDs
  • People who want a nostalgic album for their music collection
  • Anyone looking for a meaningful gift for a music lover

My Final Thoughts

When I buy Phil Collins But Seriously CD, I look for a balance of condition, sound quality, and value. If I take my time and compare listings carefully, I usually end up with a copy I feel good about owning. For me, the best purchase is the one that brings both great music and lasting satisfaction.

Final Thoughts

I think the *Phil Collins But Seriously CD* remains a standout for anyone who appreciates heartfelt songwriting and polished production. My takeaway is that it captures Phil Collins at a deeply reflective and memorable point in his career, with songs that still resonate today. If you’re looking to add a classic album to your collection, this CD is definitely one worth considering.

Author Profile

Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler
Graham Kessler has spent much of his working life figuring out how complicated products can be explained without making people feel like they need an instruction manual for the explanation itself.

Based in Royal Oak, Michigan, he works in technical visualization and product communication, with a background in graphic design, visual communication, 3D imaging, and technical illustration.

Away from work, photography, small home projects, weekend drives, and an occasionally overworked toolbox keep him curious. Through QuintekGroup.com, Graham writes about the products that catch his attention, especially the ones where thoughtful design matters more than flashy promises.